When considering adding a shed to your property, one of the primary decisions you’ll face is whether to build it yourself or purchase a pre-built structure. Each option has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the best choice depends on your specific needs, skills, and resources. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both building and buying a shed to help you make an informed decision.
Should You Build or Buy a Shed? Pros and Cons of Each

Building a Shed: Pros and Cons
Constructing a shed from scratch can be a rewarding project, offering a sense of accomplishment and the opportunity to tailor the structure to your exact specifications. However, it’s essential to weigh the benefits against the challenges.
Pros of Building a Shed
Customization: Building your own shed allows for complete control over the design, size, and features. You can tailor every aspect to meet your specific needs, whether it’s adding extra windows for natural light or creating specialized storage areas.
Cost Savings: By sourcing materials yourself and investing your own labor, you can potentially save money compared to purchasing a pre-built shed. This approach allows for flexibility in choosing materials that fit your budget.
Skill Development: Taking on the construction of a shed enhances your carpentry and project management skills. It’s an opportunity to learn and apply new techniques, which can be fulfilling and useful for future projects.
Material Quality Control: When you build the shed, you have the authority to select high-quality materials, ensuring the durability and longevity of the structure.
Cons of Building a Shed
Time-Consuming: Constructing a shed requires a significant time investment, from planning and design to gathering materials and actual construction. This can be challenging if you have a busy schedule.
Required Skills and Tools: Building a shed necessitates a certain level of carpentry skills and access to specific tools. Without these, the project can become overwhelming and may lead to subpar results.
Potential for Mistakes: Without professional experience, there’s a higher risk of errors during construction, which can compromise the shed’s structural integrity and lead to additional costs for repairs.
Permit Acquisition: In New York State, constructing a shed larger than 144 square feet requires a building permit. Navigating the permit process can be complex and time-consuming.
Buying a Shed: Pros and Cons
Purchasing a pre-built shed or a prefabricated kit offers convenience and efficiency, but it’s important to consider the potential limitations.
Pros of Buying a Shed
Time Efficiency: Buying a shed significantly reduces the time required to have a functional storage space. Many companies offer quick delivery and installation, allowing you to utilize the shed almost immediately.
Professional Craftsmanship: Pre-built sheds are constructed by experienced professionals, ensuring high-quality workmanship and adherence to industry standards. This results in a durable and reliable structure.
Warranty and Support: Many shed manufacturers, including Heritage Structures, provide warranties and customer support, offering peace of mind and protection against potential issues.
Design Variety: Manufacturers offer a wide range of designs, styles, and sizes, allowing you to choose a shed that complements your property and meets your specific requirements.
Cons of Buying a Shed
Higher Initial Cost: Purchasing a pre-built shed can be more expensive upfront compared to building one yourself, as you’re paying for both materials and professional labor.
Limited Customization: While many manufacturers offer various options, there may be limitations in customizing the shed to your exact preferences compared to building it yourself.
Delivery and Installation Constraints: Depending on your property’s location and accessibility, delivering and installing a pre-built shed may present challenges, potentially leading to additional costs.
Factors to Consider When Deciding
When choosing between building or buying a shed, consider the following factors:
Budget: Assess your financial resources to determine whether you have the funds to purchase a pre-built shed or if building one aligns better with your budget.
Time Availability: Consider how much time you can realistically dedicate to the project. Building a shed requires a substantial time commitment, whereas buying one offers immediate use.
Skill Level: Evaluate your construction skills and access to necessary tools. If you’re not confident in your abilities, purchasing a professionally built shed may be the safer option.
Customization Needs: Determine how specific your requirements are. If you need a highly customized solution, building your own shed provides greater flexibility.
Local Regulations: Research local building codes and permit requirements in your area. In New York State, sheds over 144 square feet require a building permit, which involves submitting detailed plans and paying associated fees.
Heritage Structures: Your Partner in Quality Sheds
At Heritage Structures, we’ve been specializing in building quality portable structures in New York since 2004. As a family-owned business, our core values are built on consistent quality, lasting relationships, and fair pricing. We use industry-leading materials and techniques to bring unmatched value to our customers, backed by our Lifetime Warranty. Our diverse range of sheds includes A-Frame, Gambrel Loft, Mono Pitch, and more, each customizable to fit your unique needs.
Experience Our 3D Shed Builder
To help you visualize and design your perfect shed, we offer an interactive 3D Shed Builder tool on our website. This user-friendly feature allows you to customize every aspect of your shed, from dimensions and colors to window placements and roofing materials. See your creation come to life in real-time and make adjustments as needed to ensure it meets all your specifications. Once satisfied, you can request a quote directly through the tool, streamlining the process from design to delivery.
Contact Us for a Personalized Quote
Whether you decide to build or buy, Heritage Structures is here to assist you every step of the way. Contact us today for a free quote. Our team at Heritage Structures is here to help you choose or customize a shed that fits your space, style, and budget.